Office of The State Attorney, 12th Judicial Circuit, Florida
Serving the Citizens of Sarasota, Manatee, and DeSoto Counties
Office of The State Attorney, 12th Judicial Circuit, Florida

Newsroom

PRESS RELEASE: Dominic Culpeppper

Dominic Culpeppper mugshot

State Attorney Ed Brodsky’s office announced today that the 12th Judicial Circuit Court denied Defendant Dominic Culpeppper’s Sentence review after conducting an evidentiary hearing on November 13, 2026.

On June 25, 2002, Culpepper beat sixteen-year-old Frank Wesley McCool to death with a baseball bat, then dragged his body into the woods, removed McCool’s outer clothing, and covered him with palm fronds.  After luring McCool to his home, Culpepper lay in wait with the baseball bat and struck the victim in the back of the head as he was on his knees. According to the autopsy report, Culpepper struck McCool at least 15 times, The blows fractured the victim’s skull and broke the bat.  Culpepper cleaned up the crime scene, disposed of the murder weapon, and tried to persuade other juveniles involved to lie for him.

 A jury convicted Culpepper of First-Degree Murder in February, 2002, and he was sentenced to life in prison.  Following the Supreme Court’s ruling in Miller v. Alabama which addressed juvenile remedial sentencing, Culpepper was resentenced in April 2015 by Judge Thomas Krug to 40 years in prison followed by lifetime probation. At that time, the Court ordered that Culpepper would be eligible for a sentence review under Florida Statute 921.1402 (6). 

A sentencing review pursuant to 921.1402 (6) was conducted on November 13, 2026 by Judge Andrea Decanio,12th Judicial Circuit.  As required under the statute, the    Court focused on what the juvenile has done since committing the crime and how he has changed over the years After the hearing, in which Culpepper presented four witnesses and submitted two Forensic Psychological Evaluations, the Court determined that Culpepper has not been rehabilitated and is unfit to reenter society.

The lead prosecutor in the case, Assistant State Attorney Karen Fraivillig commented: 

 “During his incarceration, Culpepper’s disciplinary history has been punctuated by repeated disciplinary referrals. His 32 prison infractions include repeated drug use as well as fighting, possession of contraband, possession of narcotics, destruction of property, unauthorized possession of a cellphone and illegal financial transactions.  Culpepper is now 39 years old, yet continues to demonstrate contempt for the law and indifference to the rules of the highly-structured prison society in which he resides.   His behavior in prison undercuts his claims of rehabilitation and his fitness to reenter society as a law-abiding citizen.

If you have any questions or would like further information, please contact Assistant State Attorney Karen Fraivillig in the Sarasota County office at 941-861-4400.